0

TODAY'S TIMES

BORROWED OPINIONS
Showdown in Arizona, Where Mariachis and Minutemen Collide

PHOENIX

Want to see America unraveling? Come here, to Thomas Road and 35th Street, to M. D. Pruitt’s furniture store. Come on Saturday morning and stand near the eight delivery trucks barricading the parking lot, like the wall of an urban Alamo.

For the last seven weeks, a sidewalk protest here by Latino immigrants has blossomed into a feverish reality show, attracting Minutemen, mariachis, children dancing in Mexican folk costume, white racists, United Nations observers, Phoenix police officers and Maricopa County sheriff’s deputies.

The weekly confrontation — strident and stalemated — perfectly mimics the national debate. But it’s a sideshow to something uglier: what happens when immigration’s complexities are handed to local law enforcers sympathetic to the fury of one side.

Thomas Road has lots of Latino day laborers, or jornaleros, who hustle for work near Home Depot. A few months ago, the Phoenix police shooed them away. They dispersed to streets nearby, angering local businesses. One of the biggest, Pruitt’s, hired off-duty city police officers to keep jornaleros at bay. The city put a stop to that, so Pruitt’s turned to the county sheriff, Joe Arpaio.

Sheriff Joe, as he is known, needed no prodding: hunting undocumented immigrants is his specialty. He has arrested hundreds under a state antismuggling law (for smuggling themselves) and has had 160 officers deputized as federal immigration agents. They have made more than 50 arrests near Pruitt’s since the protests began.

They’ll pull a car over for a traffic infraction, then check everyone’s papers. They say they act on reasonable suspicion only — if they see a shirt or shoes like those worn south of the border or hear Spanish. They say it isn’t profiling.

There is no doubt whose side Sheriff Joe is on. He has officers on Pruitt’s payroll, guarding the lot on protest days. Last week, he issued a news release demanding that the demonstrators stop hurting Pruitt’s and vowing to crank up the pressure until they went away. It was a naked attempt to stifle dissent and help a business ally.

People here are used to that from Sheriff Joe. He describes himself as “America’s meanest sheriff” and has recently been basking in the love of nativists like the Minuteman Chris Simcox and radio host Terry Anderson, who gushed over him at a roast in Sun City West this month.

If Arizona begins punishing companies that hire illegal workers under a law that takes effect Jan. 1 — a lawsuit to block it was thrown out Friday — it will fall to counties to do the purge. In Maricopa, that means Sheriff Joe.

The protests at Pruitt’s are the only real opposition he has faced. Their leader is Salvador Reza, a stocky American of Mexican and Apache ancestry, an Air Force veteran who has spent years organizing jornaleros and small-business owners here.

Mr. Reza says he can’t understand why America accepts global flows of companies, money and jobs but not workers. Why faith in market forces seems to have been eclipsed by fear of immigrants. Or why the country cannot set up legal channels to let jornaleros come and go and not be hassled.“They actually are people with a work ethic that would make the Puritans proud,” he said.

Pruitt’s owner, Roger Sensing, says he needs armed officers to protect customers from jornaleros. Mr. Reza calls that ridiculous, and one informed noncombatant, the Rev. Craig Geiger, pastor of a Lutheran church across the street, agrees. He told me he had never seen a laborer enter Pruitt’s lot. He also said his Latino congregation did not drive to church anymore. Documented or not, they fear Sheriff Joe. They walk.

Pastor Geiger leaves the neighborhood on Saturdays, because it gets deafening. When I was there, a trio singing Mexican ballads strolled through the crush. A Minuteman with a bullhorn followed them. “Monkeys coming through!” he shouted. His side rushed up to drown the music out: “Born in the U.S.A.! Born in the U.S.A.! K.K.K.! Viva la Migra! January First!”

The restrictionists see Jan. 1 as the dawn of a new era, when the Mexicans disappear and everything gets pure and legal again. It is uncertain whether Arizona’s economy will survive the exodus. “Unfortunately, they’ll probably wake up when they bankrupt the state,” Mr. Reza told me.

For a slide show and further commentary on what’s happening in Phoenix, go to nytimes.com/opinion.


Rox said:
 
I guess my question is why do these workers feel the need to turn this area into Little Mexico? Because they chose to break the law by illegally entering this country?

There's nothing wrong with protests. But if, in fact, these protests affect business owners in the area, then don't the business owners have the right to have something done about it?

I agree with Mr. Reza in wondering why legal channels can't be set up for these people to work, if, indeed, these jobs are not filled by current citizens. But instead of addressing these issues, our government (and BOTH parties) continue to ignore the issue, while laws are ignored and people like the "mean Sheriff" do their type of enforcement.

Ignoring this situation for years and years is what has got us to the point we are now. What will ignoring it longer bring?

 
posted 712 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
 
I feel they got some damned gall being here illegaly and protesting because they don't wanna think they are illegal.
Bigoted or not, I agree with Mr. Dobbs.

If the nation's law enforcement is going to look the other way for 10-20 MILLION law breakers, they should have NO RIGHT to even run a damned radar gun on me!

I don't care about color or nationality, at all.
Russians speak how many languages?
Why can't we?
That's not the deal.
If you're hear legally, I don't care if you just whistle like Harpo did!
HA!
 
posted 712 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
lindainks55 said:
 
The same thing makes me angry, Tracy. I can't even refer to them as immigrants (legal or not!) as that gives the many who came to America for opportunities a bad rap. Immigrants came here and learned this country's language, customs and pride. They worked hard to become Americans. These illegal aliens don't deserve what our country's immigrants earned.

But we must take away the opportunities and punish the businesses the bushco protects as part of the solution to this problem.
 
posted 712 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
Wendy said:
 
Yep, another soap box.

You know what, i don't care what language you speak in your home. But dammit, if you expect me to speak to you out in public, you damn well better be able to speak the same language I do. I don't understand why I, who am a citizen of this country, was born and raised HERE in this ENGLISH speaking country, should have to learn spanish in order to get by. Not that I have anything against learning a new language. Far from it. I am doing everything in my rather meager power in fact to teach my son Spanish as it is a part of his heritage. But I shouldn't have to in order for him to be able to get a job when the time comes, and that is what this is turning into. And I would like to know who decided that Spanish should be the second language of this country? What about all the other nationalities that live here? Why shouldn't we learn THEIR language if we are going to become a bi-lingual nation? Don't they deserve as much, if not more so, that opportunity, since they are here LEGALLY? Immigration means something radically different these days than it did even when I was younger! Take the Vietnamese population here for instance - you may not be able to understand any of the english they try to speak to you, but they damn sure TRY! They are the first to tell you they are Americans. So why is it that the latin american populations that are running for amnesty in our country expect us to cater to them instead of them learning how to live here? Isn't us opening the doors (inadvertant as it may be) to them enough? Why do we owe them more? Many of us struggle day to day to make a living and have the american dream. Why shouldn't they?
 
posted 712 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
 
I'm definately voting on this issue.
I don't care if I hafta vote.... (swallowing hard and grimicing) .... republican.

Ewwwww, I said it!
 
posted 712 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
lindainks55 said:
 
I've been thinking about this all afternoon, and I know its not my business but ya know I'm concerned so, I was wondering IF you vote for a Republican does that mean you need to give up sex? They seem to have some kinda hang up about sex. It's just been too long since I voted for a Republican for President and the party has changed so much, and ya know, I was just wondering.
 
posted 712 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
Rox said:
 
Linda, you only have to give up straight sex. ;) Or the missionary position, since it seems that Republican sex, when they have it, must be kinky in some way.

Okay, whoever else is reading this, I'm only joking, so no flames are necessary. Just take a deep breath and blow it out slowly, chanting "It's only a joke, it's only a joke..."
 
posted 712 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 
 
HA!
HA!
HA!
Rox rocks.
 
posted 711 days ago
Add Comment Reply to: this comment OR this thread
 

Search